By NastyNils·
Motorcycle comparison · Sport Tourer
BMW S 1000 XR (Mark 3) vs Yamaha Tracer 9 (MY2021-GT)
BMW S 1000 XR vs Yamaha Tracer 9: which one you'd rather spend the big miles on.
You'll wind the throttle open on the BMW S 1000 XR and feel the rush build hardest near the top, with the exhaust snarling you on. The Yamaha Tracer 9's triple pulls strong from low revs.
So which one do you buy?
The S 1000 XR has the edge if…
Sporty riding on twisty roads
Inches ahead: S 1000 XR
Once the road starts to bend, the S 1000 XR noses ahead. Credit stronger brakes. Your own skill counts for more than a gap this size.
Daily commuting & city riding
By a nose: S 1000 XR
For the Monday-to-Friday grind, the S 1000 XR pulls a nose in front. Your own commute could easily flip it.
Comfortable long-distance riding
Edges it: S 1000 XR
The S 1000 XR is slightly easier to live with on a long day. Put it down to more stability at speed.
Which one's the smarter buy
No clear winner on value
The S 1000 XR costs more, but the Tracer 9 doesn't automatically win on value. Neither is the clear better buy for the money. Your choice depends on what you want it for.
What makes each one tick
S 1000 XR
Perched on the tall S 1000 XR, you're sitting on a superbike's urgency with long-haul comfort wrapped around it. Its semi-active fork and shock adjust damping on the fly and stay plush over broken pavement, solo or loaded with a passenger and bags. At highway speed there's a tingly buzz in the bars and pegs that can wear on you over a long day. The engine begs for more throttle.
Tracer 9
The Tracer 9's front end drops into a corner with almost no effort and doesn't stray from its line. A bump shows that the semi-active KYB suspension's modes aren't cosmetic. Comfort and Sport ride differently.
Nils rode the Tracer 9 in 2021 (NastyNils Testride).
The Voice of Experience
What actually separates them
- The Tracer 9 has the lower seat: 31.9 in (810 mm) vs 33.1 in (840 mm).
- The Tracer 9 has the lower wet weight: 485 lb (220 kg) vs 498 lb (226 kg).
- The S 1000 XR makes more peak power: 170 hp (125 kW) vs 119 hp (88 kW).
Which one for the way you ride
A confidence-building first motorcycle
Not built for this
Neither of these is a sensible first motorcycle. Learn on something smaller and lighter, then come back.
These two run dead level on running costs. Sit on both in the showroom and trust what your body says.
Who each one is built for
What's good, and what you'll live with
S 1000 XR
What owners say
Strengths
- Comprehensive electronics package as standard
- Excellent semi-active suspension for real-world comfort
- Superbike-derived engine with addictive top-end power
Trade-offs
- Noticeable high-rpm vibration through bars and footpegs
Tracer 9
What owners say
Strengths
- Engine character — torquey, flexible CP3
- Excellent value — comprehensive standard kit
- Chassis precision and agility
- Functional semi-active KYB suspension
- Comprehensive electronics package
Trade-offs
- Wind buffeting and helmet noise
- Stock seat — slope and hardness
- Handlebar vibration zone 3.8–5.0k rpm
- Hard 1st-gear engagement and occasional false neutrals
- Two-screen TFT layout (GT only) — cluttered, daylight contrast
Known problems to check before you buy
S 1000 XR
No confirmed faults on file yet. That's not the same as fault-free.
Tracer 9
- Cruise control orange light flashes; cruise cannot be set or resumed The cruise control indicator flashes and the system refuses to set or resume. Cause traced in some cases to a sticky front-brake light switch or clutch-position switch (cruise interlocks) — sometimes resolved by an ignition cycle, sometimes requiring switch replacement; some owners report recurrence after dealer-replaced switches.
- Vibration through handlebar and footpegs in the 3,800–5,000 rpm range Owners report a buzz/numbness through the handlebar concentrated at approximately 3,800–5,000 rpm — a range that overlaps with 6th-gear highway cruising for many speeds. Smooths above approximately 5,000 rpm. Inherent to the long-stroke CP3 in this chassis.
- Front turn-signal mounting brackets work loose The front indicator stalks loosen at the bracket mounting point; light contact (e.g., a brush in the garage) can detach them. Refastening securely is difficult.
What they cost used
These prices compare a 2-year-old S 1000 XR with a 2-year-old Tracer 9.
- S 1000 XR
- about $15,100
- Tracer 9
- about $11,100
At two years old, the BMW S 1000 XR sits around $15,100 while the Yamaha Tracer 9 lands near $11,100. That's a $4,000 gap in the Tracer 9's favor. These are US market estimates, not live listings.
What they share
- Cooling
- Liquid-cooled
- Gearbox
- 6-speed
- Final drive
- Chain
- Front tire
- 120/70-17
Where the spec sheets split
| S 1000 XR | Tracer 9 | |
|---|---|---|
| Seat height | 33.1 in (840 mm) | 31.9 in (810 mm) |
| Wet weight | 498 lb (226 kg) | 485 lb (220 kg) |
| S 1000 XR | Tracer 9 | |
|---|---|---|
| Displacement | 999 cc | 890 cc |
| Engine | Inline-four | Inline-three |
| Power | 170 hp (125 kW) | 119 hp (88 kW) |
| Peak power at | 11,000 rpm | 10,000 rpm |
| Torque | 84 lb-ft (114 Nm) | 69 lb-ft (93 Nm) |
| Peak torque at | 9,250 rpm | 7,000 rpm |
| S 1000 XR | Tracer 9 | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel economy | 38 mpg (US) / 6.2 L/100 km | 43 mpg (US) / 5.5 L/100 km |
| Fuel capacity | 5.3 US gal (20 L) | 4.8 US gal (18 L) |
| S 1000 XR | Tracer 9 | |
|---|---|---|
| Front brake | 320 mm | 298 mm |
| Rear tire | 190/55-17 | 180/55-17 |
| Wheelbase | 59.9 in (1522 mm) | 59.1 in (1500 mm) |
What comes fitted, what costs extra
| S 1000 XR | Tracer 9 | |
|---|---|---|
| Cruise Control | Option | Standard |
| Quickshifter | Option | Standard |
| Smartphone Connectivity | Standard | Not offered |
| Navigation | Standard | Not offered |
| USB Charging Port | Standard | Option |
| Heated Grips | Option | Standard |
| Luggage System | Option | Standard |
Head to head, area by area
Both bikes on the same scale, one area at a time.