By ·

Motorcycle comparison · Sport Tourer

BMW S 1000 XR (Mark 3) vs Harley-Davidson Pan America 1250 ST (MY2025)

Deep into a long day, a big handful of throttle on the BMW S 1000 XR sends its inline-four snarling up the revs, and there's a tingle working into the bars. On the Harley-Davidson Pan America 1250 ST, revs don't buzz.

BMW S 1000 XR (Mark 3) and Harley-Davidson Pan America 1250 ST (MY2025) side by side
BMW S 1000 XR (Mark 3) 2024 · Superbike Engine, Touring Frame Harley-Davidson Pan America 1250 ST (MY2025) 2025 · Harley That Rides Straight

So which one do you buy?

The S 1000 XR has the edge if…

Sporty riding on twisty roads

Edges it: S 1000 XR

Once the road starts to bend, the S 1000 XR noses ahead. Credit better suspension and a sportier chassis. Your own skill counts for more than a gap this size.

The Pan America 1250 ST has the edge if…

Keeping running costs low

Nose ahead: Pan America 1250 ST

The Pan America 1250 ST is a touch easier on the wallet to run. Condition still matters more than the model.

Which one's the smarter buy

Nothing in it on value

The S 1000 XR and the Pan America 1250 ST sit close enough in price that neither is the clear better buy for the money.

What makes each one tick

S 1000 XR

There's a superbike engine in the S 1000 XR's tall frame, and it saves its real shove for the top of the tach, where the exhaust howls for more. As it turns into a corner, the semi-active suspension changes its damping on the fly and the chassis doesn't wallow, solo or two-up with full bags. Potholes go soft through the seat.

Pan America 1250 ST

After a full day on the Pan America 1250 ST, you step off fresh, because its relaxed seat-to-bar layout doesn't let fatigue pile up. The forward stretch is comfortable for most body types. Sport rubber on street-size wheels lets the bike find the apex on a glance, even when it's well into a lean. A bump halfway through the bend lands in the lowered Showa units. The front's still holding its line.

Nils rode the Pan America 1250 ST in Hungary in 2025 (NastyNils Testride).

The Voice of Experience

Portrait of NastyNils
Harley-Davidson Pan America 1250 ST (MY2025)
Nils Mueller

What actually separates them

  • The Pan America 1250 ST has the lower seat: 31.7 in (805 mm) vs 33.1 in (840 mm).
  • The S 1000 XR has the lower wet weight: 498 lb (226 kg) vs 542 lb (246 kg).
  • The S 1000 XR makes more peak power: 170 hp (125 kW) vs 150 hp (112 kW).

See every difference ↓

Which one for the way you ride

A confidence-building first motorcycle

Look elsewhere

For a brand-new rider, both are the wrong place to start. Learn the basics on a smaller bike first.

There's no real gap on commuting and long days. Sit on both and let fit and price decide.

Who each one is built for

Scenic Sport-Touring Escapist

Black Hills · Blue Ridge Parkway · Cherohala Skyway

Appalachian Technical Corner Rider

Back of the Dragon · Blue Ridge Parkway · Cherohala Skyway

Big-Mile National Park Tourer

Beartooth Highway · Blue Ridge Parkway · Going-to-the-Sun Road

What's good, and what you'll live with

S 1000 XR

What owners say

Strengths

  • Comprehensive electronics package as standard
  • Excellent semi-active suspension for real-world comfort
  • Superbike-derived engine with addictive top-end power

Trade-offs

  • Noticeable high-rpm vibration through bars and footpegs

Pan America 1250 ST

From Nils' own saddle time

Strengths

  • Steps Off Fresh After Miles
  • Trustworthy Throttle Manners
  • Sport Rubber On Street Wheels
  • Sharp, Trustworthy Front Brakes
  • Deep Electronics Package

Trade-offs

  • No Theatrical Top-End Hit
  • Ceiling Against True Sport-Tourers
  • Geometry Limits Hang-Off
  • Reach Isn't Adjustable

What they cost used

These prices compare a 1-year-old S 1000 XR with a 1-year-old Pan America 1250 ST.

S 1000 XR
about $17,000
Pan America 1250 ST
about $17,200

What they share

Cooling
Liquid-cooled
Gearbox
6-speed
Final drive
Chain
Fork
Upside-down (USD)
Front brake
320 mm
Front tire
120/70-17

Where the spec sheets split

Seat height and weight
S 1000 XR Pan America 1250 ST
Seat height 33.1 in (840 mm) 31.7 in (805 mm)
Wet weight 498 lb (226 kg) 542 lb (246 kg)
Engine, power and torque
S 1000 XR Pan America 1250 ST
Displacement 999 cc 1252 cc
Engine Inline-four 60° V-twin
Power 170 hp (125 kW) 150 hp (112 kW)
Torque 84 lb-ft (114 Nm) 91 lb-ft (123 Nm)
Fuel economy and tank capacity
S 1000 XR Pan America 1250 ST
Fuel economy 38 mpg (US) / 6.2 L/100 km 42 mpg (US) / 5.6 L/100 km
Fuel capacity 5.3 US gal (20 L) 5.6 US gal (21.2 L)
Other specifications
S 1000 XR Pan America 1250 ST
Rear tire 190/55-17 180/55-17
Wheelbase 59.9 in (1522 mm) 61.8 in (1570 mm)

What comes fitted, what costs extra

S 1000 XR Pan America 1250 ST
Electronic Suspension Standard Not offered
Cruise Control Option Standard
Quickshifter Option Standard
Heated Grips Option Standard
Adjustable Windscreen Standard Not offered

Head to head, area by area

Both bikes on the same scale, one area at a time.

Braking

Engine

Handling

Suspension

Comfort

Reliability

Practicality

Sporting Capability

Usability

Specs and equipment as of October 31, 2026. The riding calls use the same ratings behind both buyer's guides.