By NastyNils·
Motorcycle comparison · Scrambler
Triumph Scrambler 1200 XE (DS01) vs BMW R nineT Scrambler (K23)
Into a tight, rutted bend, the Triumph Scrambler 1200 XE tucks in around you, and it's already pointed where you're looking. The BMW R nineT Scrambler tips in, then sits planted.
So which one do you buy?
The Scrambler 1200 XE has the edge if…
Real off-road capability
A touch ahead: Scrambler 1200 XE
Off the pavement, the Scrambler 1200 XE asks a bit less of you. That comes from more suspension adjustment. The gap won't matter much on easy gravel.
Sporty riding on twisty roads
Narrow edge: Scrambler 1200 XE
Once the road starts to bend, the Scrambler 1200 XE noses ahead. Put it down to better suspension and stronger brakes. Your own skill counts for more than a gap this size.
The R nineT Scrambler has the edge if…
Character, looks and sound
Edges it: R nineT Scrambler
On sound and soul, the R nineT Scrambler comes out a touch ahead. It's down to more retro style and a purer look. Your own eyes and ears outrank this verdict.
Which one's the smarter buy
Nothing in it on value
Neither bike is the clear better buy for the money. The used prices sit close enough that the choice comes down to what you want from the ride.
What makes each one tick
Scrambler 1200 XE
You can run the Scrambler 1200 XE down the freeway and you'll still swing onto a rough dirt road without a second thought. The parallel twin's tuned for low and middle revs, and the throttle answers with a pull that hooks up on loose ground. Walking-pace turns take real work. The fork soaks up the trail and keeps climbing.
Nils rode the Scrambler 1200 XE in Styria in 2019 (NastyNils Testride).
R nineT Scrambler
On the Blue Ridge Parkway, the R nineT Scrambler's boxer twin pulls hard from low revs, and there's plenty of shove before the needle climbs. Corner entry comes quick and light. Once it's leaned over, the steel tubular frame holds a steady line. The boxer drives hard out of every curve.
The Voice of Experience
What actually separates them
- The R nineT Scrambler has the lower seat: 32.3 in (820 mm) vs 34.3 in (870 mm).
- The R nineT Scrambler makes more peak power: 110 hp (81 kW) vs 89 hp (66 kW).
- The R nineT Scrambler makes more peak torque: 86 lb-ft (116 Nm) vs 81 lb-ft (110 Nm).
Which one for the way you ride
Comfortable long-distance riding
Both miss here
For all-day comfort, both fall short. Keep the rides short and you'll get on fine with either.
Count commuting as a draw. The deal on the table and the condition of the bike matter more here.
Who each one is built for
What's good, and what you'll live with
Scrambler 1200 XE
Strengths
- Composed at highway speed
- Öhlins shrug off the rough
- Superbike-grade brake hardware
- Real freeway and dirt range
- Premium in every detail
Trade-offs
- Right calf cooks in traffic
- Unwieldy at walking pace
- Not for rusty or new riders
- Full wind blast at speed
- Heavy for genuine technical off-road use
R nineT Scrambler
What owners say
Strengths
- Torquey characterful boxer twin
- Iconic retro styling and customisation potential
Trade-offs
- Uncomfortable seat for long rides
Known problems to check before you buy
Scrambler 1200 XE
- Rear shock preload adjuster access difficult The Öhlins piggyback shocks are fully adjustable but preload adjustment requires C-spanner and removal of side panels for proper access, complicating quick load changes.
- Spoke tension on tubeless wheels requires monitoring The tubeless spoked wheels, while excellent for off-road use, can develop loose spokes after sustained rough riding; periodic spoke tension checks are recommended in the owner's manual.
- Clutch slave cylinder seal leak Some owners report hydraulic fluid weeping from the clutch slave cylinder, sometimes causing soft lever or clutch slip; usually addressed under warranty with seal or unit replacement.
- Headlight bracket / mounting vibration on rough surfaces On heavy off-road or washboard surfaces, headlight assembly and surrounding brackets can develop loosened fasteners; routine torque checks recommended.
- TFT display readability in direct sunlight The full-colour TFT instrument can wash out in bright direct sunlight, particularly with the lighter display theme.
R nineT Scrambler
- Wiring loom chafing on steering movement (early models) On early production models, the wiring loom near the steering head could rub and cause electrical failures to the headlight or instruments. BMW later added a plastic sheath.
- Engine oil consumption (especially early miles) Some riders report noticeable oil consumption in the first 10,000 miles, requiring regular top-ups. Usually resolves as the engine breaks in.
What they cost used
These prices compare a 6-year-old Scrambler 1200 XE with a 6-year-old R nineT Scrambler.
- Scrambler 1200 XE
- about $8,700
- R nineT Scrambler
- about $8,000
What they share
- Gearbox
- 6-speed
Where the spec sheets split
| Scrambler 1200 XE | R nineT Scrambler | |
|---|---|---|
| Seat height | 34.3 in (870 mm) | 32.3 in (820 mm) |
| Scrambler 1200 XE | R nineT Scrambler | |
|---|---|---|
| Displacement | 1200 cc | 1170 cc |
| Engine | Parallel twin | Flat-twin (boxer) |
| Cooling | Liquid-cooled | Air/oil-cooled |
| Power | 89 hp (66 kW) | 110 hp (81 kW) |
| Peak power at | 7,400 rpm | 7,250 rpm |
| Torque | 81 lb-ft (110 Nm) | 86 lb-ft (116 Nm) |
| Peak torque at | 3,950 rpm | 6,000 rpm |
| Scrambler 1200 XE | R nineT Scrambler | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel economy | 51 mpg (US) / 4.6 L/100 km | 46 mpg (US) / 5.1 L/100 km |
| Fuel capacity | 4.2 US gal (16 L) | 4.5 US gal (17 L) |
| Scrambler 1200 XE | R nineT Scrambler | |
|---|---|---|
| Final drive | Chain | Shaft |
| Fork | Upside-down (USD) | Telescopic |
| Front tire | 90/90-21 | 120/70-19 |
| Rear tire | 150/70-17 | 170/60-17 |
| Ground clearance | 9.8 in (250 mm) | 6.1 in (155 mm) |
| Front travel | 9.8 in (250 mm) | 4.9 in (124 mm) |
| Rear travel | 9.8 in (250 mm) | 5.5 in (140 mm) |
What comes fitted, what costs extra
| Scrambler 1200 XE | R nineT Scrambler | |
|---|---|---|
| Traction Control | Standard | Option |
| Ride Modes | Standard | Not offered |
| Manually Adjustable Front Suspension | Standard | Not offered |
| Cruise Control | Standard | Not offered |
| USB Charging Port | Standard | Not offered |
| Heated Grips | Standard | Option |
Head to head, area by area
Both bikes on the same scale, one area at a time.