By NastyNils·
Motorcycle comparison · Supersport
BMW S 1000 RR (K46) vs HP4 (K42)
BMW S 1000 RR vs HP4: which one to buy for the riding you do.
You'll barely register the BMW S 1000 RR's electronics on a wet, bumpy stretch, because it's already corrected and moved on. The BMW HP4 resets its damping and glides across the bumps.
So which one do you buy?
Which one's the smarter buy
Money won't decide it
Neither bike is the clear better buy at these used prices. The S 1000 RR costs less, but that doesn't make it the smarter spend.
What makes each one tick
S 1000 RR
On a long, fast sweeper at WeatherTech Raceway Laguna Seca, the S 1000 RR's twin-spar frame stays settled in the lean, and the front doesn't wander. Turning in, the bars put it on a neutral line. Off the apex, the rear tire hooks up without a stutter. You're on the gas early.
Nils rode the S 1000 RR in Portugal in 2009, in Andalusia, Austria, Slovakia, and the Czech Republic in 2010, in Andalusia, Hungary, Slovakia, and the Eifel in 2011, in Andalusia and Spain in 2012, in 2014, in Andalusia in 2015, in Oman & UAE in 2016, and in Qatar in 2017 (NastyNils Testride).
HP4
On forged wheels, the HP4 doesn't need more than a light push on the bar to snap from one lean to the next. Hauling it down from speed, the Brembo monoblocs clamp with serious force, and there's clear feel at the lever. The throttle brings a thick wallop of torque through the middle revs, yet the electronics keep that shove in check. Up top, the four keeps rushing.
The Voice of Experience
What actually separates them
- The HP4 has the lower wet weight: 439 lb (199 kg) vs 450 lb (204 kg).
- ABS: standard on the HP4, option on the S 1000 RR.
- Wheelie Control: standard on the HP4, option on the S 1000 RR.
Which one for the way you ride
A confidence-building first motorcycle
Both fall short
Learning on either of these is the hard way. A gentler bike will make you a better rider sooner.
They come out level on track days, commuting, twisty roads, and running costs. The better-kept used example is the smarter money.
Who each one is built for
What's good, and what you'll live with
S 1000 RR
Strengths
- Top End Never Signs Off
- Traction Control That Trims
- Clutchless In Both Directions
- Planted In Fast Sweepers
- Class-leading peak power
Trade-offs
- It Does Not Flick
- Thin Below The Power Band
- City Riding Is Work
- Brake Lever Point Migrates
- Snatchy throttle response (2010–2011)
HP4
What owners say
Strengths
- Monstrous yet manageable power
- Revolutionary semi-active suspension
- Exceptional electronics package
- Monobloc Brembo brakes with race-derived ABS
Trade-offs
- High entry and running costs
Known problems to check before you buy
S 1000 RR
- Fuel pump flange may crack and leak fuel Recall 20V471000 The pneumatic fastening tool used at the fuel-pump supplier introduced stress at the pump flange during assembly. Over time, cracks can propagate at the flange and fuel can leak — fire risk in the presence of an ignition source. The recall covers MY2010–MY2011 S 1000 RR within a much larger 50,184-unit BMW two-wheel campaign that also covered other BMW Motorrad models. Remedy: dealer reinforces the flange with a support ring or replaces the fuel pump. A follow-up campaign (NHTSA 20V471) replaces fuel pumps that received only the support-ring repair under 13V617.
- Sachs suspension underdamped for spirited / track use (especially 2010) The 2010 Sachs front fork is widely judged underdamped for spirited or track use; damping was improved in 2011 within the same generation. Cartridge re-valving is non-trivial because Sachs uses non-standard shim sizes — most track riders fit aftermarket cartridge kits. The Sachs rear shock is not user-rebuildable, and seal leaks have been reported.
- Quickshifter intermittent or inoperative — wiring/connector at shift sensor Quickshifter stops working intermittently or completely. Documented root cause is most often the wiring or connector at the shift-sensor side rather than the sensor itself; BMW issued a service measure on the shift sensor. Some dealers misdiagnose and replace the sensor unnecessarily before fixing the wiring.
- Balance-pipe / exhaust valve servomotor failure On MY2015–2016 K46 bikes (and some MY2017–2018), the balance-pipe valve servomotor bushing wears, the actuating cables can break, or the servo can seize in the activated position. Symptom: loud clicking on ignition, fault code, valve stuck open or closed. BMW has replaced full header systems under warranty in some documented cases. Aftermarket "servo eliminator" devices (HealTech, Servo Buddy) are common workarounds.
- DDC dashboard error / calibration failure On MY2015–2018 K46 bikes optioned with DDC (Dynamic Damping Control), a "DDC!" dashboard warning or calibration failure can appear. Documented root causes include corroded or loose battery terminals, CAN-bus faults, and rear travel sensor displacement. Often resolves with re-calibration or wiring fix; in some cases the DDC shock has been replaced under warranty.
- Brake judder / pulsing at the lever, mostly under track / hard road use Brake judder reported at the lever after hard use. Community consensus is that the cause is most often uneven pad-material deposit on the stock rotors (rather than true disc warpage), with stock pads judged inadequate for sustained track use. Common owner fix: switch to higher-spec pads (e.g., Brembo Z04) or upgraded discs.
- Cam chain rattle at cold start (cam chain tensioner spring pressure) Loud cam chain rattle, particularly on cold start. BMW issued a service measure that replaces the original BLACK screw plug at the cam chain tensioner with a longer SILVER screw plug to increase tensioner spring pressure. The fix is applied only after approximately 9,300 mi (15,000 km) and only when the symptom is documented. Some owners switch to aftermarket manual cam chain tensioners (e.g., Alpha Racing) for track use. No engine failures attributed to the rattle in documented sources.
- Vibration through tank, handlebars and pegs above 6,000 rpm Distinct vibration through tank, bars, footpegs and mirrors, intensifying past approximately 10,000 rpm. The K46 inline-four has no secondary balancer. Mirrors can blur at sustained high revs.
- Aluminium frame transfers significant heat to rider's inner legs The aluminium twin-spar frame (used as a load-bearing element with the engine inclined into it) transfers significant engine and exhaust heat to the rider's inner legs, particularly in low-speed traffic and warm weather. Documented across all K46 model years. Common owner-installed mitigation: aftermarket carbon frame covers (e.g., Ilmberger).
HP4
- Fuel pump failure (Recall 21V-060) Recall 21V060000 Affected units may experience fuel pump failure, leading to engine stalling. BMW issued a safety recall for 2011-2014 S1000RR and HP4 models.
What they cost used
These prices compare a 12-year-old S 1000 RR with a 12-year-old HP4.
- S 1000 RR
- about $12,600
- HP4
- about $15,400
At 12 years old, the S 1000 RR sits around $12,600 while the HP4 holds near $15,400. That's a $2,800 gap in the S 1000 RR's favor. These are US market estimates, not live listings.
What they share
- Displacement
- 999 cc
- Engine
- Inline-four
- Cooling
- Liquid-cooled
- Fuel capacity
- 4.6 US gal (17.5 L)
- Gearbox
- 6-speed
- Final drive
- Chain
Where the spec sheets split
| S 1000 RR | HP4 | |
|---|---|---|
| Seat height | 32.1 in (815 mm) | 32.3 in (820 mm) |
| Wet weight | 450 lb (204 kg) | 439 lb (199 kg) |
| S 1000 RR | HP4 | |
|---|---|---|
| Power | 199 hp (146 kW) | 193 hp (142 kW) |
| Torque | 83 lb-ft (113 Nm) | 83 lb-ft (112 Nm) |
| S 1000 RR | HP4 | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel economy | 37 mpg (US) / 6.4 L/100 km | 36 mpg (US) / 6.6 L/100 km |
| S 1000 RR | HP4 | |
|---|---|---|
| Front tire | 120/70 ZR17 | 120/70-17 |
| Rear tire | 190/55 ZR17 | 200/55-17 |
What comes fitted, what costs extra
| S 1000 RR | HP4 | |
|---|---|---|
| ABS | Option | Standard |
| Wheelie Control | Option | Standard |
| Launch Control | Option | Standard |
| Quickshifter | Option | Standard |
Head to head, area by area
Both bikes on the same scale, one area at a time.