By NastyNils·
Motorcycle comparison · Sport Tourer vs Supersport
BMW R 1200 S (MY2006) vs HP2 Sport (MY2008)
BMW R 1200 S vs HP2 Sport: two kinds of bike, and who each one is for.
Out of a bend, the BMW R 1200 S's shaft drive and sport chassis don't ride like any chain sportbike. The BMW HP2 Sport's rear digs in and doesn't pump.
So which one do you buy?
Buy the R 1200 S if…
Traveling with luggage
Clear pick: R 1200 S
On a loaded road trip, the R 1200 S comes out clearly ahead. Thank more range per tank and better wind protection for that.
The R 1200 S has the edge if…
Daily commuting & city riding
Edges it: R 1200 S
Your daily ride leans slightly toward the R 1200 S. Fit and price can easily outweigh that.
The HP2 Sport has the edge if…
Sporty riding on twisty roads
Slight edge: HP2 Sport
On a twisty road, the HP2 Sport edges ahead. Most of that is lighter steering and better suspension. Not by enough to settle it alone.
What makes each one tick
R 1200 S
A second powerband wakes the R 1200 S's boxer high in the revs, and it's still pulling hard at the redline. On the Blue Ridge Parkway's fast sweepers, the brake lever trims speed and turn-in wants a deliberate push on the bar. Leaned over, the Telelever front holds the arc.
HP2 Sport
Wide open, the HP2 Sport's boxer screams until the quickshifter cracks in the next gear and the pull loads straight back up. Corner entry stays calm over a bump with the brakes still on, because the Telelever doesn't dive and the fork keeps its full travel. You'll commit to the turn earlier. The lever reads the front contact patch.
Nils rode the HP2 Sport in Hungary and the Czech Republic in 2009 (NastyNils Testride).
The Voice of Experience
What actually separates them
- The HP2 Sport has the lower wet weight: 439 lb (199 kg) vs 470 lb (213 kg).
- The HP2 Sport makes more peak power: 133 hp (98 kW) vs 122 hp (90 kW).
- The R 1200 S has the larger fuel tank: 4.5 US gal (17 L) vs 4.2 US gal (16 L).
Which one for the way you ride
Comfortable long-distance riding
Off its turf: HP2 Sport
Long days on the highway aren't the HP2 Sport's job, so there's no verdict for it here.
A confidence-building first motorcycle
Wrong job for both
Learning on either of these is the hard way. A gentler bike will make you a better rider sooner.
Who each one is built for
What's good, and what you'll live with
R 1200 S
What owners say
Strengths
- Impressive build quality and reliability
- Rev-happy boxer engine with strong top-end
- Shaft-drive sportbike with unique character
HP2 Sport
Strengths
- Built like a race bike
- Brakes talk to your fingers
- Telelever keeps the travel
- Quickshifter that actually works
- Quick without wearing you out
Trade-offs
- Boxer heads limit lean
- Rev ceiling comes early
- Throttle stumble with miles
- High premium price
Known problems to check before you buy
R 1200 S
- Fuel pump flange recall (NHTSA 13V617) – risk of fuel leak and fire Recall 13V617000 The original fuel pump flange may crack, causing fuel leakage and increased fire risk. BMW issued a recall to inspect and replace the flange on affected motorcycles, including the R1200S.
- Rear wheel flange recall (NHTSA 15V-141) – possible cracking Recall 15V141000 The rear wheel flange can develop cracks on some 2006–2008 R1200S motorcycles, potentially leading to wheel failure. BMW recalled affected units to replace the flange.
HP2 Sport
- Fuel pump flange may leak Recall 20V471000 A potential crack in the fuel pump flange can lead to a fuel leak. BMW issued a recall (NHTSA 20V471) to replace the fuel pump assembly. Affected HP2 Sport models from 2007–2010.
What they share
- Seat height
- 32.7 in (830 mm)
- Displacement
- 1170 cc
- Engine
- Flat-twin (boxer)
- Gearbox
- 6-speed
- Final drive
- Shaft
- Fork
- Telelever
- Front brake
- 320 mm
- Front tire
- 120/70-17
Where the spec sheets split
| R 1200 S | HP2 Sport | |
|---|---|---|
| Wet weight | 470 lb (213 kg) | 439 lb (199 kg) |
| R 1200 S | HP2 Sport | |
|---|---|---|
| Cooling | Air/oil-cooled | Air-cooled |
| Power | 122 hp (90 kW) | 133 hp (98 kW) |
| Peak power at | 8,250 rpm | 8,750 rpm |
| Torque | 83 lb-ft (112 Nm) | 85 lb-ft (115 Nm) |
| Top speed | 148 mph (238 km/h) | 155 mph (250 km/h) |
| R 1200 S | HP2 Sport | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel economy | 37 mpg (US) / 6.28 L/100 km | 29 mpg (US) / 8 L/100 km |
| Fuel capacity | 4.5 US gal (17 L) | 4.2 US gal (16 L) |
| R 1200 S | HP2 Sport | |
|---|---|---|
| Rear tire | 180/55-17 | 190/55-17 |
What comes fitted, what costs extra
| R 1200 S | HP2 Sport | |
|---|---|---|
| Manually Adjustable Front Suspension | Option | Standard |
| Quickshifter | Not offered | Standard |
Head to head, area by area
Both bikes on the same scale, one area at a time.