By NastyNils·
Motorcycle comparison · Cruiser
Harley-Davidson Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special (XL1200XS) vs Indian Scout (MY2015)
You'll crack the throttle of the Harley-Davidson Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special at a light, and it's already shoving you forward before the revs even climb. The Indian Scout's twin keeps pulling in one smooth line.
So which one do you buy?
The Scout has the edge if…
Sporty riding on twisty roads
Inches ahead: Scout
The Scout nudges ahead once the pavement starts to wiggle. Credit lighter steering and a sportier chassis. Don't expect a night-and-day difference.
Daily commuting & city riding
Narrow edge: Scout
For the ride to work, the Scout noses ahead. Most of that is friendlier manners and lower running costs. Don't let that alone make the call.
Keeping running costs low
Edges it: Scout
Day to day, the Scout works out slightly cheaper to own. The saving is small.
Which one's the smarter buy
No clear winner on value
The price gap doesn't produce a clear winner. Neither bike is the clear better buy for the money.
What makes each one tick
Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special
Down low, the Forty-Eight Special's air-cooled Evolution V-twin thumps from idle with a deep rumble. Each turn of the throttle brings a heave of torque, and there's no wait for the tach to swing. Stiff rear shocks don't forgive bumps. Its Evolution engine lives for short, hard blasts.
Scout
On Iron Mountain Road, the Scout's cast aluminum frame answers the bar quickly, and there's room to lean before anything scrapes. The liquid-cooled engine hauls hard without ever turning coarse as it spins up. The clutch doesn't snatch. The gearbox clicks through each shift cleanly.
Nils rode the Scout in the Canary Islands in 2021 (NastyNils Testride).
The Voice of Experience
What actually separates them
- The Scout has the lower seat: 26.6 in (675 mm) vs 27.8 in (706 mm).
- The Scout makes more peak power: 100 hp (75 kW) vs 66 hp (49 kW).
- The Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special has the larger engine: 1202 cc vs 1133 cc.
Which one for the way you ride
Comfortable long-distance riding
Not built for this
Both of these get tiring on a long day. A proper tourer will treat you better on big miles.
These two run dead level on character. Sit on both in the showroom and trust what your body says.
Who each one is built for
What's good, and what you'll live with
Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special
What owners say
Strengths
- Tons of low-down torque
Trade-offs
- Tiny fuel tank limits practicality
- Stiff suspension and limited cornering clearance
Scout
What owners say
Strengths
- Low seat height for approachability
- Smooth and powerful engine
- Good clutch feel and gearbox
Known problems to check before you buy
Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special
No confirmed faults on file yet. That's not the same as fault-free.
Scout
- Rear brake master cylinder recall (2015, NHTSA Recall 15V-142) Recall 15V142000 Approximately 806 early 2015 Scouts were recalled due to a potential rear brake master cylinder issue that could reduce braking power. Authorized dealers inspect and replace the component free of charge.
What they cost used
These prices compare a 6-year-old Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special with a 6-year-old Scout.
- Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special
- about $7,800
- Scout
- about $9,000
At six years old, the Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special sits around $7,800 while the Scout runs about $9,000. That's a $1,200 gap in the Harley's favor. These are estimates from the used market, not live listings.
What they share
- Final drive
- Belt
- Front tire
- 130/90-16
- Rear tire
- 150/80-16
Where the spec sheets split
| Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special | Scout | |
|---|---|---|
| Seat height | 27.8 in (706 mm) | 26.6 in (675 mm) |
| Wet weight | 564 lb (256 kg) | 558 lb (253 kg) |
| Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special | Scout | |
|---|---|---|
| Displacement | 1202 cc | 1133 cc |
| Engine | 45° V-twin | 60° V-twin |
| Cooling | Air-cooled | Liquid-cooled |
| Power | 66 hp (49 kW) | 100 hp (75 kW) |
| Torque | 71 lb-ft (96 Nm) | 72 lb-ft (98 Nm) |
| Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special | Scout | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel economy | 48 mpg (US) / 4.9 L/100 km | 44 mpg (US) / 5.4 L/100 km |
| Fuel capacity | 2.1 US gal (7.9 L) | 3.3 US gal (12.5 L) |
| Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special | Scout | |
|---|---|---|
| Gearbox | 5-speed | 6-speed |
| Wheelbase | 58.9 in (1495 mm) | 61.5 in (1562 mm) |
What comes fitted, what costs extra
| Sportster XL 1200XS Forty-Eight Special | Scout | |
|---|---|---|
| ABS | Option | Standard (from 2016) |
Head to head, area by area
Both bikes on the same scale, one area at a time.