By NastyNils·
Motorcycle comparison · Adventure vs Enduro
BMW G 650 GS (R131) vs G 650 Xchallenge (MY2007)
BMW G 650 GS vs G 650 Xchallenge: two kinds of bike, and who each one is for.
You'll feel how little the BMW G 650 GS's bars buzz at highway pace: your mind stays on the road, not your hands. On the BMW G 650 Xchallenge, the high bars stand you up on the pegs, and your legs don't quit for hours. Up there, it tracks wherever you point it.
So which one do you buy?
The G 650 GS has the edge if…
Daily commuting & city riding
By a nose: G 650 GS
The G 650 GS makes slightly more sense as a commuter. Most of that is easier everyday riding. Don't read much into a gap this small.
A confidence-building first motorcycle
Slight edge: G 650 GS
The G 650 GS is slightly friendlier for a newer rider. Credit more comfort.
The G 650 Xchallenge has the edge if…
Sporty riding on twisty roads
Small edge: G 650 Xchallenge
Through a string of corners, the G 650 Xchallenge feels a little more eager. It's down to harder acceleration and stronger brakes. The gap is small, so ride both.
What makes each one tick
G 650 GS
Stop-and-go traffic isn't a chore at the G 650 GS's clutch lever, which pulls in with almost no effort. Past town speeds, the single's in no rush to wind up. A frost heave sinks into 6.7 in (170 mm) of fork travel, and the seat's still a comfortable place to sit. Both boots find the asphalt.
Nils rode the G 650 GS in Andalusia in 2011 (NastyNils Testride).
G 650 Xchallenge
The Xchallenge settles into rutted gravel and doesn't hunt down the grooves. Preload, compression, and rebound damping are all adjustable. At walking pace in tight trees, it'll hold the exact line you pick. On Kane Creek, there's smooth pull from the liquid-cooled single as the throttle opens. At speed, the rear tire digs.
Nils rode the G 650 Xchallenge in 2007, and in Spain in 2011 (NastyNils Testride).
The Voice of Experience
What actually separates them
- The G 650 GS has the lower seat: 31.5 in (800 mm) vs 36.6 in (930 mm).
- The G 650 Xchallenge has the lower wet weight: 348 lb (158 kg) vs 423 lb (192 kg).
- The G 650 Xchallenge makes more peak power: 53 hp (39 kW) vs 48 hp (35 kW).
Which one for the way you ride
Real off-road capability
Wrong tool: G 650 GS
There's no dirt verdict for the G 650 GS. Its talents are on the road.
There's no real gap on running costs. Sit on both and let fit and price decide.
Who each one is built for
What's good, and what you'll live with
G 650 GS
Strengths
- Punches above its power
- Planted at speed
- Genuinely cheap to run
- Excellent fuel economy
Trade-offs
- Trip computer out of reach
- Swingarm shows the budget
- Look-alike filler caps
- Prone to surface rust
G 650 Xchallenge
Strengths
- Air suspension finds balance
- Standing position sorted from factory
- Full-spec front brake
- Long service intervals
- Punches above its power
Trade-offs
- Seat is rock hard
- Painted panels scratch easily
- Mass tells when it's down
- Orphan model with dwindling parts support
Known problems to check before you buy
G 650 GS
- Engine stalling from ECU software defect Recall 16V689000 Affected models (2013–2015) may stall when the clutch is engaged at idle, increasing crash risk. BMW issued a recall (NHTSA 16V689) to reprogram the ECU. The issue can recur, and a second recall was issued to supersede the first.
- Hot starting difficulty The engine is hard to start when hot due to a malfunctioning exhaust camshaft decompression mechanism, often requiring multiple cranking attempts or waiting for the engine to cool down.
G 650 Xchallenge
- Roll gear pin mount fracture (recall 10V273000) Recall 10V273000 The roll gear pin's mounting bracket can break, potentially causing chain derailment and rear wheel lockup. Recall involves replacing the bracket.
- Fuel line leakage (recall 08V-106) Recall 08V106000 Fuel lines may have been damaged during manufacturing, leading to leaks at the fabric inlay or cracks in the line itself. BMW recalled all 2007 G 650 X models to replace the lines.
- Premature rear air shock failure The stock air shock frequently loses pressure and leaks, sometimes with no warning. Many owners replace it with a conventional coil-over shock.
What they share
- Displacement
- 652 cc
- Engine
- Single-cylinder
- Cooling
- Liquid-cooled
- Torque
- 44 lb-ft (60 Nm)
- Gearbox
- 5-speed
- Final drive
- Chain
- Front brake
- 300 mm
Where the spec sheets split
| G 650 GS | G 650 Xchallenge | |
|---|---|---|
| Seat height | 31.5 in (800 mm) | 36.6 in (930 mm) |
| Wet weight | 423 lb (192 kg) | 348 lb (158 kg) |
| G 650 GS | G 650 Xchallenge | |
|---|---|---|
| Power | 48 hp (35 kW) | 53 hp (39 kW) |
| Peak power at | 6,500 rpm | 7,000 rpm |
| Peak torque at | 5,200 rpm | 5,250 rpm |
| G 650 GS | G 650 Xchallenge | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel capacity | 3.7 US gal (14 L) | 2.5 US gal (9.5 L) |
| G 650 GS | G 650 Xchallenge | |
|---|---|---|
| Fork | Telescopic | Upside-down (USD) |
| Front tire | 100/90-19 | 90/90-21 |
| Rear tire | 140/80-17 | 140/80-18 |
| Wheelbase | 58.1 in (1477 mm) | 59.1 in (1500 mm) |
| Ground clearance | 6.5 in (165 mm) | 9.8 in (250 mm) |
| Front travel | 6.7 in (170 mm) | 10.6 in (270 mm) |
| Rear travel | 6.5 in (165 mm) | 10.6 in (270 mm) |
What comes fitted, what costs extra
| G 650 GS | G 650 Xchallenge | |
|---|---|---|
| Manually Adjustable Front Suspension | Not offered | Standard |
| Heated Grips | Option | Not offered |
Head to head, area by area
Both bikes on the same scale, one area at a time.