By NastyNils·
Motorcycle comparison · Cruiser vs Tourer
Indian Chief (MY2022) vs Springfield (MY2016)
Indian Chief vs Springfield: where they split, and which one to buy.
Tip the Indian Chief into a bend and it's flicking in almost before you've asked. The Indian Springfield turns in with traction talking clearly through the front as the pace climbs. Then it holds its line and won't be argued off.
So which one do you buy?
Which one's the smarter buy
Two different jobs
The Chief costs less, but the Springfield does a different job. Neither is the clear better buy for the money.
What makes each one tick
Chief
Weight carried low keeps the Chief settled at speed, and the Thunderstroke twin doesn't wait for revs once the throttle cracks open. Torque's there from the bottom and keeps shoving through the gears. Mid pegs keep the stance neutral. The exhaust answers each twist with a low boom.
Springfield
Down low, the Springfield's Thunder Stroke twin pulls clean instead of kicking. You can set your speed with the grip or the gearbox, and it'll answer either one without fuss. There's enough lean clearance to make Iron Mountain Road's tightest switchbacks fun on 855 lb (388 kg) of bike. Hours in, the seat's still comfortable.
Nils rode the Springfield in 2019 (NastyNils Testride).
The Voice of Experience
What actually separates them
- The Chief has the lower wet weight: 670 lb (304 kg) vs 855 lb (388 kg).
- The Springfield makes more peak torque: 119 lb-ft (162 Nm) vs 108 lb-ft (146 Nm).
- The Springfield has the larger fuel tank: 5.5 US gal (20.8 L) vs 4.0 US gal (15.1 L).
Which one for the way you ride
Daily commuting & city riding
No verdict: Springfield
There's no daily-ride verdict for the Springfield. Getting to work isn't its job.
Comfortable long-distance riding
Off its turf: Chief
There's no comfort verdict for the Chief here. Its job is somewhere else.
A confidence-building first motorcycle
Look elsewhere
As first bikes, both are a stretch. Starting smaller isn't a step down.
Don't look for a gap on twisty roads and running costs: there isn't one. Go by how each one fits you.
Who each one is built for
What's good, and what you'll live with
Chief
What owners say
Strengths
- Powerful and responsive engine
- Nimble handling with a low center of gravity
Springfield
From Nils' own saddle time
Strengths
- Thunder Worth Hearing
- Torque Without the Kick
- Rock-Steady at Speed
- More Lean Than It Looks
- A Seat Built for Miles
Trade-offs
- Buffeting Above Cruising Pace
- Narrow Saddlebag Openings
- Hot-Day Engine Cut-Outs
- Three Recalls to Verify
Known problems to check before you buy
Chief
- Side stand may not fold rearward (Recall 22V-957) Recall 22V957000 The sidestand may not retract fully when it contacts the ground, posing a crash hazard. A recall has been issued for free repair by authorized dealers.
- Fuel pump failure (Recall I-22-06) Recall 22V837000 The fuel pump may fail during operation, causing the engine to stall. A recall covers replacement at no cost to the owner.
Springfield
- Fuel rail abrasion may cause fuel leak (recall 16V877) Recall 16V877000 Insufficient clearance between the fuel rail and engine can cause abrasion, leading to a potential fuel leak. Dealers will install a bracket to limit movement.
- Gear position switch false neutral indication (NHTSA Recall 19V-776) Recall 19V776000 Oxidation on gear position switch contacts may cause incorrect gear display, potentially indicating neutral when in gear, increasing risk of unintended movement. Recall/stop-sale issued (I-19-02).
- Loss of forward lighting due to VCM connector failure (recall 22V635) Recall 22V635000 The electrical connection for the Vehicle Control Module (VCM) may fail, cutting forward lighting. The high beam indicator will flash if this occurs. Dealers will inspect the connector and update software.
What they cost used
These prices compare a 3-year-old Chief with a 3-year-old Springfield.
- Chief
- $14,300
- Springfield
- $17,000
At three years old, the Indian Chief sits around $14,300 while the Indian Springfield runs about $17,000. That's a $2,700 gap in the Chief's favor. These figures come from earlier US market records, not live listings.
What they share
- Displacement
- 1811 cc
- Cooling
- Air-cooled
- Gearbox
- 6-speed
Where the spec sheets split
| Chief | Springfield | |
|---|---|---|
| Seat height | 26.2 in (665 mm) | 26.0 in (660 mm) |
| Wet weight | 670 lb (304 kg) | 855 lb (388 kg) |
| Chief | Springfield | |
|---|---|---|
| Torque | 108 lb-ft (146 Nm) | 119 lb-ft (162 Nm) |
| Chief | Springfield | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel capacity | 4.0 US gal (15.1 L) | 5.5 US gal (20.8 L) |
| Chief | Springfield | |
|---|---|---|
| Front tire | 130/60-19 | 130/90-16 |
| Rear tire | 180/65-16 | 180/60-16 |
What comes fitted, what costs extra
| Chief | Springfield | |
|---|---|---|
| Ride Modes | Standard | Not offered |
| Smartphone Connectivity | Standard | Not offered |
| Navigation | Option | Not offered |
| Tire Pressure Monitoring (TPMS) | Not offered | Standard |
| Luggage System | Not offered | Standard |
Head to head, area by area
Both bikes on the same scale, one area at a time.