By NastyNils·
Motorcycle comparison · Cruiser
Indian Chief (MY2022) vs BMW R 18 Roctane (MY2023)
Indian Chief vs BMW R 18 Roctane: which one to buy once you're past the looks.
Crack the Indian Chief's throttle and it's already pulling, eager right up through the revs. On the BMW R 18 Roctane, that same twist wakes a boxer that's thrumming deep under you. It keeps shoving from any speed and doesn't let up.
So which one do you buy?
The Chief has the edge if…
Sporty riding on twisty roads
A touch ahead: Chief
Back-road fun leans slightly toward the Chief. It's down to stronger brakes. It's a narrow call, so trust your test ride.
The R 18 Roctane has the edge if…
Character, looks and sound
Inches ahead: R 18 Roctane
On style, the R 18 Roctane makes a slightly stronger case. Thank more retro style and more distinctive styling for that. Go see both in person.
Which one's the smarter buy
Depends what you want it for
The lower sticker price doesn't settle which one is the better buy. Neither is the clear better buy for the money.
What makes each one tick
Chief
The Chief carries its weight low, and the balanced chassis doesn't get ruffled as the pace climbs. Corner entry takes no fuss. The front flicks in and won't wander off its line on Iron Mountain Road. Its pipes ring with a classic V-twin note.
R 18 Roctane
The twin pounds out old-school throb. At walking pace, 825 lb (374 kg) won't let a U-turn happen without planning. In long sweepers, the tall front stays planted.
The Voice of Experience
What actually separates them
- The Chief has the lower seat: 26.2 in (665 mm) vs 28.3 in (720 mm).
- The Chief has the lower wet weight: 670 lb (304 kg) vs 825 lb (374 kg).
- The R 18 Roctane makes more peak torque: 117 lb-ft (158 Nm) vs 108 lb-ft (146 Nm).
Which one for the way you ride
Daily commuting & city riding
Sits this out: R 18 Roctane
Weekday traffic isn't the R 18 Roctane's world, so it isn't rated here.
Comfortable long-distance riding
Not built for it: Chief
There's no comfort verdict for the Chief here. Its job is somewhere else.
On running costs, these two are a wash. That's where your budget and your inseam get the final say.
Who each one is built for
What's good, and what you'll live with
Chief
What owners say
Strengths
- Powerful and responsive engine
- Nimble handling with a low center of gravity
R 18 Roctane
What owners say
Strengths
- Massive torque and addictive engine character
- Stunning custom-inspired styling
- Comfortable, accessible ergonomics
- Improved handling and ground clearance
Trade-offs
- Excessive weight hampers low-speed manoeuvres
Known problems to check before you buy
Chief
- Side stand may not fold rearward (Recall 22V-957) Recall 22V957000 The sidestand may not retract fully when it contacts the ground, posing a crash hazard. A recall has been issued for free repair by authorized dealers.
- Fuel pump failure (Recall I-22-06) Recall 22V837000 The fuel pump may fail during operation, causing the engine to stall. A recall covers replacement at no cost to the owner.
R 18 Roctane
- Reverse gear control unit seal failure and overheating Recall 24V716000 The seal of the reverse gear control unit may deteriorate, allowing moisture ingress that causes internal corrosion and potential overheating. In rare cases this can lead to a thermal event or fire.
What they cost used
Both bikes priced used at the same age: 3 years old.
- Chief
- about $14,300
- R 18 Roctane
- about $12,200
At three years old, the Indian Chief sits around $14,300 while the BMW R 18 Roctane lands near $12,200. That puts the BMW about $2,100 cheaper. These are US market estimates, not live listings.
What they share
- Gearbox
- 6-speed
Where the spec sheets split
| Chief | R 18 Roctane | |
|---|---|---|
| Seat height | 26.2 in (665 mm) | 28.3 in (720 mm) |
| Wet weight | 670 lb (304 kg) | 825 lb (374 kg) |
| Chief | R 18 Roctane | |
|---|---|---|
| Displacement | 1811 cc | 1802 cc |
| Cooling | Air-cooled | Air/oil-cooled |
| Torque | 108 lb-ft (146 Nm) | 117 lb-ft (158 Nm) |
| Chief | R 18 Roctane | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel capacity | 4.0 US gal (15.1 L) | 4.2 US gal (16 L) |
| Chief | R 18 Roctane | |
|---|---|---|
| Final drive | Belt | Shaft |
| Front tire | 130/60-19 | 120/70-21 |
| Rear tire | 180/65-16 | 180/55-18 |
Head to head, area by area
Both bikes on the same scale, one area at a time.